tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post557632562484701890..comments2024-02-26T10:14:10.039-08:00Comments on Deflation Land: This week in thrift-store bookschristiangustafsonhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/07216348353801614419noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post-77021192867992942672013-11-24T21:03:21.580-08:002013-11-24T21:03:21.580-08:00I was at Chicago when Francis Fukuyama published h...I was at Chicago when Francis Fukuyama published his <i>End of History</i>, and we were very excited reading it, because he understood Straussian political philosophy as well as economics. At the time, it seemed like he was bridging the two schools. I also bought into his optimism for the future, granting even that there were some serious difficulties, such as how the worsening debt situation would ever turn out in the West. It was an exciting time, I was reading a lot of Hegel, too, drinking pretty deeply from the well.<br /><br />So you see the progression I have made from young idealistic optimist to some very dark pessimism, circling back around to Malthus.<br /><br />My main book pal was Roger Carlson at the Bookman's Alley shop in Evanston. I spent a lot of time and scarce money in his legendary shop.<br /><br />I would always find the best books in Evanston, because Northwestern students don't give a shit about books! LOLchristiangustafsonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07216348353801614419noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post-57212493654107178202013-11-24T20:32:21.728-08:002013-11-24T20:32:21.728-08:00Wonderful that you caught that last wave at UoC. A...Wonderful that you caught that last wave at UoC. And interesting that you, who admire Mises, studied under Bloom. As you know, there is great enmity between the Straussians and the Austrian School ( Claremont absolutely hates the LVM Institute ). <br /><br />I read RAVELSTEIN about 10 years ago and enjoyed it. You probably know that friendship between Epstein and Bellow ended over Shils. According to Epstein, the Shils character in RAVELSTEIN was one of Bellow's trademark literary hit-jobs ( later Joe returned the favor with his short story "MY BROTHER ELI" ). <br /><br />Who are the great men? Hell if I know. Would V.S. Naipaul and Cormac McCarthy qualify? I like the theologian David Bentley Hart. But my personal 20th century favs are Solzhenitsyn and Eric Voegelin. <br /><br />BTW, did you ever chat with cantankerous Bill @ GALLERY BOOKS on Belmont near the Brown line? I'll be there over next week when my wife and I visit her relatives in Ravenswood.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post-43956547191270773722013-11-24T19:23:33.857-08:002013-11-24T19:23:33.857-08:00You know, ikh I really enjoyed reading Saul Bellow...You know, <b>ikh</b> I really enjoyed reading Saul Bellow's book <i>Ravelstein</i>, his novel about the last days of Allan Bloom. Edward Shils is represented in the book as well, it's a great read.<br /><br />The relationship between Joseph Epstein and Edward Shils is analogous to that of Saul Bellow and Allan Bloom. Both Epstein and Bellow are good men, very good men, who know they are in the presence of even better men, the best of men.<br /><br />Who are the great men alive today?<br />christiangustafsonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07216348353801614419noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post-84791472352021274852013-11-24T19:00:22.879-08:002013-11-24T19:00:22.879-08:00Hehe, thanks ikh, I appreciate it. I never did me...Hehe, thanks <b>ikh</b>, I appreciate it. I never did meet Joseph Epstein, who was teaching at Northwestern back then. I was introduced to Shils by one of his best students, Steven Grosby, who came out of the Committee for Social Thought and now teaches at Clemson.<br /><br />I managed to catch the tail-end of the era of great Chicago professors, including Shils and Allan Bloom. I was young and foolish and overwhelmed by it all at the time, of course, and probably squandered many great opportunities to be around these magnificent men. Shils died in 1995, Bloom in 1993.<br /><br />With Shils you were quickly exposed to the economist Frank Knight, whose scholarship is far-ranging way beyond the limits of narrow economics as we think of it today. From there, it was easy to arrive at the Austrians, particularly Mises and Hayek, and a grand critique of the situation we are in.<br /><br />Allan Bloom was about pure political philosophy, not modern value-neutral social science. At the end of the day, the Straussians are a band of good right-wing Nietzscheans, they teach fundamentals, and are not tied to modernity per se. Their approach can be liberating, participating in the grand traditions of the West, trying to free oneself of the modern horizons.<br /><br />I think of these men quite a bit today, after many years, and I wish I could consult them for advice, dial them up like Obi-wan Kenobi. What would Shils think of K-winter theory, and how would he react to the idea that this was all a cycle and that the USD -- and quite possibly America -- could collapse? <br /><br />To what extent were these great men even trapped by their own horizons, the meaty good years of the 20th Century? <br /><br />We are so poor now not to have them with us to help us understand a very difficult future.<br /><br />christiangustafsonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07216348353801614419noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-547276048038789798.post-19960250245805384782013-11-24T18:19:50.783-08:002013-11-24T18:19:50.783-08:00I always knew you were smart CG, so U of Chic does...I always knew you were smart CG, so U of Chic doesn't surprise me. But that studied under Shils marks you as older than I thought ( what with all the epic solo hikes through Cascadia I couldn't imagine you over 40 ). <br /><br />I only know Shils' name via Joseph Epstein's essay "My Friend Edward". Some hilarious anecdotes in that piece.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.com